Hello and welcome to Wyrd Wessex! In our latest episode, we took a deep dive into one of the most chilling and perplexing mysteries in all of the British Isles: the legend of the Big Grey Man of Ben Macdui. This isn't your typical ghost story. It’s a decades-old enigma haunting Scotland’s second-highest peak, where something unseen has been terrifying some of the world's most experienced mountaineers.
The Most Famous Encounter
The story's roots go back to 1891 with the renowned Professor J. Norman Collie. As a distinguished chemist, a pioneering mountaineer, and a Fellow of the Royal Society, Collie was not a man prone to flights of fancy. Yet, while descending the mountain in a dense mist, he heard something unnerving: giant footsteps following him, taking strides three or four times the length of his own. Overcome with an indescribable terror, he ran blindly for miles, later confessing that something was "very queer about the top of Ben Macdui" and he would never return.
A Mountain of Unsettling Stories
Collie's account was far from an isolated incident. Over the years, countless other climbers have reported similar, and sometimes even stranger, experiences:
The "Psychic" Encounter: Mountaineer Peter Densham twice had a deep sense of dread on the mountain, once feeling a cold pressure on his neck and a force pushing him toward a deadly cliff.
The Brown Creature: A friend of climber Richard Frere, attempting to spend a night alone on the summit, was terrorized by an intense sense of presence before witnessing a massive, brown, swaggering creature he estimated to be over 20 feet tall.
The Demonic Sighting: A respected lawyer and veteran mountaineer, George Duncan, was so shaken by his sighting of a devil-like figure in a black robe on the mountain's slopes that he felt a cold shiver run down his spine, an experience he never had before or since.
Beyond the Grey Man
The mystery isn't limited to just a spectral figure. The mountain seems to be a nexus for all sorts of unusual phenomena.
Ghostly Music and Voices: Many have reported hearing beautiful, swelling pipe music, baritone voices singing, and even a "spectral orchestra" in the silent, misty conditions.
Time Slip Visions: Mountaineer Frank S. Smythe had a vivid and terrifying vision of a massacre on the mountain, an event he later learned was historically plausible for the area.
Benevolent Beings: Not all encounters were frightening. Mahayana Buddhist Captain Sir Hugh Rankin and his wife saw and conversed with a tall, peaceful figure they instantly recognized as a Bodhisattva, a perfected being of their faith.
Explaining the Unexplained
So, what is the Big Grey Man of Ben Macdui? The logical brain offers a few explanations:
Brocken Spectre: An optical illusion where a person's shadow is magnified and distorted by mist.
Infrasound: Low-frequency sound waves generated by wind and geology that can cause feelings of anxiety, dread, and a sense of presence.
Hallucination: The extreme isolation, fatigue, and cold can certainly play tricks on the mind.
But as we highlighted in the episode, the most compelling part of this legend is that these experiences are reported almost exclusively on Ben Macdui by some of the most seasoned and rational climbers in the world. Whatever the cause—be it scientific, paranormal, or something completely unknown—it's clear that this mountain holds a secret that continues to fascinate and terrify to this day.
For more deep dives into the weird and wonderful, be sure to check out our latest episode and follow us on our socials! You can also find our show on Substack at weirdwessex.co.uk to get notifications about new content.
Stay Wyrd!