The Enduring Enigma of Nessie: A Deep Dive into the Loch Ness Monster Legend

From ancient Celtic myths to modern-day viral videos, the legend of the Loch Ness Monster, affectionately nicknamed Nessie, has persisted for centuries. This elusive creature, said to inhabit the murky depths of Scotland's most famous loch, continues to capture the imagination of people worldwide. But what is the truth behind the myth? Join us as we explore the history of Nessie sightings, the various theories surrounding its existence, and the enduring appeal of this legendary cryptid.

A Touch of the Occult: Alister Crowley's Influence

Before we dive into the loch, we need to address a rather… unconventional theory. The infamous Aleister Crowley, known as "the wickedest man in the world," once owned Boleskine House, situated on the shores of Loch Ness. Intriguingly, the house was built on the site of a former church, rumored to have been consumed by flames, killing the entire congregation. Crowley, believing the location held significant power, performed rituals from The Book of Abramelin there, intending to invoke his Guardian Angel. These rituals, requiring months of preparation and abstinence, also involved summoning the 12 Kings and Dukes of Hell. Legend has it that Crowley never banished these summoned demons, potentially contributing to the strange occurrences at the house and perhaps even influencing the Nessie myth itself. Locals even claimed he regularly sacrificed sheep into the loch for his "pet monster."

Early Encounters: From Saints to Sea Serpents (and Misidentified Ponies)

The earliest recorded sighting of Nessie dates back to the 6th century AD, in the biography of Saint Columba. This account, written by Adomnán, describes a water beast that attacked a man near Loch Ness, only to be repelled by Columba's command. While this tale is steeped in religious lore, it establishes a long-standing tradition of monstrous encounters in the loch. Later accounts, often from the 19th century, describe strange creatures in the loch. In 1853, residents at Lochend panicked over unusual creatures, fearing a sea serpent. The alarm subsided when the "monsters" were revealed to be two stray ponies from a nearby estate. In 1868, large, dead fish, about 2 meters long, washed ashore at Abriachan. Locals suspected a strange creature, but they were later identified as skinned dolphins, likely a prank by some mischievous fishermen. These early sightings, while sometimes comical in retrospect, show the long history of strange things being seen in the Loch.

The Modern Myth: A Monster Emerges and a Hotel Manager's Tale

The Nessie we know today began to take shape in the 20th century. A pivotal moment occurred in 1933 with Mrs. Mackay's sighting of a "whale-like" creature in Loch Ness. As the manageress of the Drumnadrochit Hotel (which later became the Loch Ness Exhibition Centre!), her account, along with increasing media attention, propelled Nessie into the public consciousness. This event, more than any other, solidified the creature as a popular topic of discussion and speculation.

A Prehistoric Animal on the Road: Mr. Spicer's Sighting

Shortly after Mrs. Mackay's sighting, Mr. Spicer had his own encounter. Driving along the southern shore of Loch Ness on a hot afternoon, he witnessed "a most extraordinary form of animal" crossing the road in front of him. He described it as resembling a dragon or a prehistoric animal, with a long neck and a ponderous body. The fleeting glimpse reminded him of a Diplodocus, a long-necked dinosaur, he had recently seen in the film "King Kong."

The First Photo (Maybe a Dog?) and the Hippo Footprint Hoax

The first photograph claimed to depict the Loch Ness Monster was taken on November 12, 1933, by Hugh Gray. The blurry image sparked immediate interest, but closer examination suggested it might be Gray's Labrador dog, which he was walking at the time. The original negative is lost, but analysis of contact prints revealed an otter, further casting doubt on the photo's authenticity. In December of the same year, the Daily Mail hired big-game hunter Marmaduke Wetherell to find Nessie. He found large footprints, initially believed to belong to a "very powerful soft-footed animal about 20 feet long.” However, these tracks were later revealed to be a hoax, made with an umbrella stand or ashtray that had a hippopotamus leg as a base.

Arthur Grant's Close Encounter: A Seal-Plesiosaur Hybrid or an Otter?

In January 1934, Arthur Grant, a veterinary student, had a close encounter while riding his motorcycle near Abriachan. He nearly collided with a large, serpentine creature with a small head and a long neck. Grant described it as a hybrid of a seal and a plesiosaur, and even created a sketch of the creature. However, zoologist Maurice Burton later analyzed the sketch and concluded it was consistent with an otter.

The "Surgeon's Photo" Debunked: A Toy Submarine's Revenge

The "surgeon's photograph," taken in 1934 by Robert Kenneth Wilson, became iconic, seemingly providing definitive proof of Nessie's existence. Years later, it was revealed to be an elaborate hoax. Christian Spurling, son-in-law of M.A. Wetherell (the same hunter from the hippo footprint hoax), confessed that the photo was a fabrication. The creature depicted was a toy submarine, modified with a wooden neck, created as revenge against the Daily Mail, which had previously ridiculed Wetherell.

The 1934 Expedition: A Seal and a Lost Film

In 1934, Sir Edward Mountain funded a large expedition to investigate Nessie. Twenty men were hired as "watchers," and 21 photographs were taken, but none were conclusive. Captain James Fraser captured film footage near Urquhart Castle, which, while sadly lost, was initially believed by scientists to show a living animal (later identified as a seal).

The 2018 Study: Eels, "Unexplained" DNA, and a Lack of Monsters

In 2018, a scientific study led by geneticist Neil Gemmell used environmental DNA analysis to identify species in Loch Ness. The study found a diverse ecosystem, including fish, deer, pigs, birds, humans, and bacteria. While no large, unknown creatures were found, the study did detect a significant amount of eel DNA, leaving open the possibility of a giant eel. Intriguingly, 20% of the DNA collected was "unexplained," suggesting the potential for undiscovered species or genetic variations.

The Loch's Secrets: Size, Volume, and Radioactive Sediment

Loch Ness is a truly massive body of water. It’s nearly 23 miles long and its volume is so great that it could contain all the other lakes in England and Wales combined, and it could hold the world's population 15 times over. This vastness, coupled with layers of radioactive sediment (one layer from Chernobyl), contributes to the mystery.

The Hunt Continues: Modern Quests and Past Incinerations

Despite numerous searches, no conclusive evidence of Nessie has ever been found. Even recent large-scale "monster hunts," involving hundreds of people, have come up empty. This elusiveness fuels the legend. And speaking of strange things, remember that time we reported that Nessie had been incinerated? (Just kidding… mostly.)

Conclusion: The Mystery Endures

The story of Nessie is a fascinating blend of folklore, eyewitness accounts, scientific investigations, hoaxes, and human imagination. While conclusive evidence of its existence remains elusive, the legend of the Loch Ness Monster continues to thrive. Whether Nessie is a real creature, a misidentified animal, or simply a product of our collective imagination, the mystery endures, reminding us of the enduring power of myth and the allure of the unknown.

Check out our episode on the Loch Ness Monster here

Or watch on our YouTube Channel here